Sunday, February 13, 2011

Clash of Cultures

Dylan Richards

Throughout history, old and new often clash. The transition can range from a mere inconvenience to matters that people kill each other over. I remember my parents becoming very annoyed when they had to switch from VCR to DVD because Blockbuster stopped renting out VCR cassettes. This, however, pales in comparison to the hundred or so deaths caused by the riots and the subsequent change of government in Egypt over the course of this last month. Although I’m sure somebody was unfortunate enough to die over the change from VCR to DVD. Many paradigm shifts can be seen in Virginia Woolf’s Mrs. Dalloway, and the clash between an old way of life and a new one can easily be seen.

As Stephen Kern says in The Culture of Time and Space, “The traditional world was rooted in conventions that dictated how an individual should experience his own self, other people, and objects in the world….as the entire world was ordered in discrete and mutually exclusive forms: solid/porous, opaque/transparent, inside/outside, public/private, city/country, noble/common, countryman/foreigner, framed/open, actor/audience, ego/object, and space/time.” (209-210) While little in Mrs. Dalloway is explicitly revealed, the reader can see that the distinction between the old way of life and the new one is clashing. Take for example when a car backfires on Bard street. Mrs. Dalloway comes to the conclusion that it is most likely the Queen in the car, and metaphorically this represents the change in the social stratum that happened around this time. Lower classes on the street mix with middle/upper class like Mrs. Dalloway who at that moment mix with the highest of the nobility.

Mrs. Dalloway’s relationship with her husband and her friend Sally Seton further show the difference between old and new. Mrs. Dalloway says, “…she could not dispel a virginity preserved through childbirth which clung to her like a sheet.” (Woolf, 30) Mrs. Dalloway is either still a virgin which means that her marriage was never consummated, or she may feel that her virginity is tied to being in love with her husband, which the reader finds out is not the case. Like the older concept of marriage, love had little to do with upper class marriages. Mrs. Dalloway then realizes that she had been in love, but not with a man. She had been in love with a friend of hers, Sally Seton. This love may have been platonic, but most likely it was homosexual in nature. This represents a newer viewpoint on love, but because Mrs. Dalloway still must deal with older conventions on love and marriage, she hides her true feelings.

The world in which Mrs. Dalloway inhabits is one which changes between the old social norms and new ones. Modern technology, but in particular World War One, changed how people interacted and felt about others and ushered in the modern world. Mrs. Dalloway exhibits the change in culture, both wanting to be free of old conventions but at the same time trapped in them.

Kern, Stephen. "The Nature of Time." The Culture of Time and Space 1880-1918. Cambridge, MA: Harvard UP, 1983

Woolf, Virginia. Mrs. Dalloway. Orlando: Harcourt, Inc. 1925

2 comments:

  1. I think it is interesting that Mrs. Dalloway was living in a world that was experiencing great changes. I wonder if she knew how profound the changes were that were taking place in her lifetime. Maybe society today has gone through changes recently comparable to the changes that Mrs. Dalloway experienced. It's seems normal to me- but maybe the changes will seem profound a hundred years from now.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This gets me to thinking: what are the conventions of today? I know that dating has changed dramatically with the liberality that we accept nowadays. I know that a lot of people advocate individualism or "doing it your own way." Point is, I do not think that we really follow any conventions anymore. It is that whole idea that we have lost structure to our lives. Granted, structure has been a problem for humanity in the past, but now that we have broken "free of old conventions" like Mrs. Dalloway was so wanting for, we have run amok with our freedom.

    We are like a child who had admired a certain plaything, yet because of his parents strict rules, he was not able to get it. Once he was able to convince his parents to give him that one toy (or by capitalism, once he was able to achieve that toy), he was so happy. But then he saw the next best thing and had to have that. Soon the boy could not have enough toys.
    We have done that as humanity. We cannot have enough freedom.

    We may boast that America is the land of the free, but have we perverted our freedom into structureless lives? Are we now not the land of the free, but the land of the wild?

    ReplyDelete